Slobodan Milošević;
(20
August 1941
– 11
March 2006)
was President
of Serbia and of Yugoslavia.
He served as President of Serbia
from 1989 to 1997 and then President of the Federal
Republic of Yugoslavia from 1997 to 2000. He also led Serbia's Socialist
Party from its foundation in 1992 to 2001.
He was one of the
key figures in the Yugoslav
wars during the 1990s and Kosovo
War in 1999. He was indicted in May 1999, during the Kosovo
War, by the UN's
International
Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia for crimes
against humanity in Kosovo, charges of genocide
in Bosnia, crimes
against humanity, and grave breaches of the Geneva
Conventions. Violations of the laws or customs of war in Bosnia
and Croatia were added a year and a half after that.
He was forced to
resign following a
popular uprising against his rule. A year later Milošević was
extradited to stand trial in the The
Hague but died after five years in prison with just fifty hours
of testimony left before the conclusion of the trial. Milošević,
who suffered from chronic heart ailments, high blood
pressure and diabetes,
died of a heart
attack.
Early life
Milošević was a Montenegrin
Serb
by origin, born in Požarevac,
Serbia,
during the Axis
occupation. His parents separated soon after he was born; his father,
Svetozar Milošević, a deacon
in the Serbian
Orthodox Church committed suicide
in 1962, and his mother, Stanislava Milošević, a school teacher,
hanged herself in 1974.
He went on to study
law at Belgrade
University, where he became the head of the ideology committee
of the Communist Party's student branch. While at the university, he
befriended Ivan
Stambolić, whose uncle had been a prime minister of Serbia.
This was to prove a crucial connection for Milošević's career
prospects, as Stambolić sponsored his rise through the Communist
hierarchy.
On leaving
university, Milošević became an economic advisor to the Mayor of Belgrade
in 1960. Five years later he married Mirjana
Marković, whom he had known since childhood. Markovic would
have some influence on her husband's political career both before
and after his rise to power; she was also leader of Milošević's
junior coalition partner, Yugoslav
United Left in the 1990s. In 1968 he got a job at the Tehnogas
company, where Stambolić was working, and became its chairman in
1973. By 1978 Stambolić's sponsorship had enabled Milošević to
become the head of Beobanka, one of Yugoslavia's largest banks; his
frequent trips to Paris
and New
York gave him the opportunity to learn English
and French,
both of which were to be considerable assets in his political
career.
Rise to power
Milošević was
elected president of the Belgrade City Committee of the League of
Communists in April 1984, again replacing Stambolić, who had moved
on to the post of head of the Serbian Communist Party. At this time
Milošević publicly opposed nationalism; he prevented the
publication of a book containing the works of Slobodan
Jovanović, a distinguished Serbian historian, law professor and
nationalist politician of the early twentieth century. Milošević
also advocated retaining Marxism
as a school subject and publicly lambasted Belgrade's youth for
their low turnout at the Communist Day of the Youth, claiming
that their absence "desecrated" Tito's
character and work.
Milošević emerged
in April 1987 as the leading force in Serbian
politics. His political positions have sometimes been termed as nationalist
(though there is no indication of that in quotes or acts from Milošević
in those years), although socialism and internationalism
also marked his ideology. Later that year, while addressing a
Serbian crowd in Kosovo
gathered to protest about alleged brutality by local police, he told
them that "No one has the right to beat you! No one will ever
beat you again!".
This broke two
important taboos in Yugoslav politics; that Communist officials
should not publicly criticise their peers (the police were
controlled by the local Communist administration) and that Party
officials should not publicly side with one of Yugoslavia's ethnic
groups (the local administration was dominated by ethnic Albanians,
which the Kosovo Serbs resented). Stambolić later said that "he
had seen that day as the end of Yugoslavia".
At the same time,
Milošević's message was in accordance with internationalism
cornerstone principle of the Communist's party, which tells that no
ethnic group has any precedence over another. With the statement,
Milošević tried to insure this policy with the message that
Albanians of Kosovo can not use police to oppress and abuse local
Serbs.
Meanwhile, Stambolić
had become the President
of Serbia. To the dismay of senior figures in the party, he
supported Milošević for election as the new party leader. Stambolić
spent three days advocating Milošević as leader, managing to
secure him by the narrowest margin in the history of Serbian
Communist Party internal elections.
Dragiša
Pavlović, a Stambolić ally and Milošević's fairly liberal
successor at the head of the Belgrade Committee of the party,
opposed Milošević's policies towards Kosovan Serbs. Contrary to
advice from Stambolić, Milošević denounced Pavlović as being
soft on Albanian
radicals. Milošević had prepared the ground by quietly replacing
Stambolić's supporters with his own people; on 23
September and 24
September, during a thirty-hour session of the Communist Central
Committee broadcast live on state television, Milošević had
Pavlović deposed. Embarrassed and under pressure from Milošević's
supporters, Stambolić resigned a few days later.
In February 1988,
Stambolić's resignation was formalized, allowing Milošević to
take his place as President. Twelve years later, in the summer of
2000, Stambolić was kidnapped; his body was found in 2003 and Milošević
was charged with ordering his murder. In 2005, several members of
the Serbian secret police and criminal gangs were convicted in
Belgrade for a number of murders, including Stambolić's.
Milošević spent
most of 1988/1989 focusing his politics on the "Kosovo problem".
His subordinates organized public demonstrations – the
so-called "anti-bureaucratic revolution" – which led
to the elected leaderships of Vojvodina
(6
October 1988),
Montenegro
(10
January 1989),
and finally Kosovo
itself (in February-March 1989) being removed. Azem
Vllasi, leader of the Kosovo Albanian majority, was arrested and
a strike by Kosovar miners was violently crushed by the Serbian
police, killing 32 people.
On 28
March 1989, the National
Assembly of Serbia, under Milošević's leadership, amended the
Serbian constitution to greatly reduce the autonomy of its two
provinces. The decision was hugely controversial, especially in
Kosovo, where many Albanians had never accepted the legitimacy of
Serbia's annexation of the province in 1912. A harsh regime was
imposed which attracted widespread criticism from international
human rights organisations, transnational bodies such as the
European Community and other foreign governments. This caused great
alarm in the other republics of Yugoslavia, where concerns were
expressed that their own autonomous status could come under threat.
As nationalism grew
within Yugoslavia, Milošević sought major constitutional changes.
The 1974 Yugoslav
Constitution had organised the country so that Serbia's status
as the largest and most populous republic was counterbalanced by the
way that the other republics were represented. The socialist
Yugoslavia was at the time governed by an eight-member Presidency,
representing the six republics plus Kosovo and Vojvodina. By ousting
the government of Montenegro and replacing it with a more compliant
one, Milošević effectively secured that republic's vote for
himself; likewise the abolition of the autonomous governments of
Vojvodina and Kosovo ensured that he controlled those votes as well.
The Presidency was thus divided down the middle between Milošević's
supporters and his opponents in the other republics, with four votes
for each side. The result was stalemate and an increasing paralysis
of Yugoslavia's federal government.
At the 14th
Congress of the League
of Communists of Yugoslavia in January 1990, Milošević's
Serbian delegation campaigned for major constitutional changes which
would give greater political power too. Slovenian
and Croatian
delegations (led by Milan
Kučan and Ivica
Račan respectively) strongly opposed this, seeing it as an
attack on their own republics' status, and left the Congress in
protest. This caused a deep rift in the League of Communists and
effectively put an end to the Party as a unified organisation.
With the collapse
of the Yugoslav League of Communists, Milošević presided over the
Serbian party's transformation into the Socialist
Party of Serbia (July 1990) and the adoption of a new Serbian
constitution (September 1990) providing for the direct election of a
president with increased powers. Milošević was subsequently
re-elected president of the Serbian
Republic in the direct elections of December 1990 and December 1992.
In the first free
parliamentary elections of December 1990, Milošević's Socialist
Party won 80.5% of the vote. The ethnic Albanians in Kosovo largely
boycotted the election, effectively eliminating even what little
opposition Milošević had. Milošević himself won the presidential
election with an even higher percentage of the vote. Although the
elections could not have been described as wholly free and fair
– Milošević controlled much of the media as well as the
election system itself – there is little doubt that at this
time he genuinely enjoyed mass popular support in Serbia.
Milošević's rise
to power happened amidst a growth of nationalism in all the former
Yugoslavian republics following the collapse of communist
governments throughout eastern
Europe. In 1990, Slovenians
elected a nationalist government under Milan
Kučan, and the Croatians
did the same with Franjo
Tuđman. Communist single-party rule in Bosnia
and Herzegovina was replaced by an unstable coalition of three
ethnically-based parties.
The Yugoslav Wars
Yugoslavia's
collapse became inevitable by the start of 1991, with the federal
institutions completely deadlocked between pro- and anti-Milošević
forces. In a televised address on 16
March 1991 Milošević declared that Yugoslavia was finished and
that Serbia would no longer be bound by decisions of the Federal
Presidency.
In June 1991,
Slovenia and Croatia seceded from the federation, followed by the
republics of Macedonia (September 1991) and Bosnia and Herzegovina (March
1992). The Yugoslav
People's Army (JNA) sought unsuccessfully to prevent Slovenia's
secession by the use of force; however, Slovenia's Ten-Day
War ended in a disastrous defeat for the federal forces. At this
point, Milošević adopted a policy of establishing "all Serbs
in one state," based on the ostensible premise that the large
Serbian populations in Croatia (580,000) and Bosnia (1.36 million)
should have the right to stay in Yugoslavia as they desired, arguing
that the Yugoslav Constitution gave the right of self-determination
to nations (Serbs, Croats, etc as a whole), not republics (Croatia,
Bosnia, Serbia, etc).
This policy –
characterised by critics as a "Greater
Serbia" in all but name – was, however, certain to
produce a violent conflict. The Serb minorities lived, for the most
part, in ethnically mixed areas with large non-Serb populations in
their midst. Their areas were also not contiguous with Serbia itself.
Croatia's Serbs
began campaigning for autonomy or independence from Croatia as early
as mid-1990 after the election of the Croatian nationalist Franjo
Tudjman, with Milošević's full support. Through 1991 and early
1992, together with the Yugoslav
People's Army, they engaged in a war against the Croatian
government. The first leader of Serbs in Croatia, Milan
Babić, has stated that Milošević was responsible for this and
his successor Goran
Hadžić publicly bragged about how he was "the extended
hand of Slobodan Milošević".
War crimes
prosecutors subsequently characterised the creation of the
separatist Republic
of Serbian Krajina as a "joint criminal enterprise"
whose goal was "the forcible removal of the majority of the
Croat and other non-Serb population from the approximately one-third
of the territory of the Republic of Croatia that he planned to
become part of a new Serb-dominated state." At the trial of
Milan Babić, the ICTY found that the Serbian government was
directly involved in the Croatian Serb rebellion, providing supplies,
weapons, money and leadership.
In 1992, Bosnia
and Herzegovina was plunged into war even before its formal
declaration of independence. Bosnian Serb forces soon captured as
much as 70% of the country, expelling hundreds of thousands of
non-Serbs and killing many thousands more, often in atrocities such
as the Srebrenica
massacre. Again, war crimes prosecutors have characterised this
as a "joint criminal enterprise" in which Milošević
played a leading part. The ICTY likewise found that the Serbian
government was directly involved in the conflict.
By 1995, however,
the ongoing wars in Croatia and Bosnia had become an unsupportable
burden for Serbia. The country had experienced hyperinflation
and a drastic worsening of living standards, due to an economic
collapse and the effect of international sanctions. Milošević
sought to force the Croatian and Bosnian Serbs to the negotiating
table but was rebuffed by their nationalist leaderships. In response,
despite his earlier support for their rebellions, he let it be known
that they were on their own.
The Croatian
War was brought to an end in August 1995 when Croatia's Operation
Storm rapidly overran the Republic of Serbian Krajina. Almost
the entire Croatian Serb population was expelled from Croatia in the
process, fleeing into Bosnia and Serbia. Only a month later, the
Bosnian Serbs were brought to the brink of military collapse by a
combination of NATO
air strikes (Operation
Deliberate Force) and a joint Croatian/Bosniak ground offensive
(Operation
Mistral). Again, many hundreds of thousands of Serbs were forced
into exile.
Milošević
subsequently negotiated the Dayton
Agreement in the name of the Bosnian Serbs, ending the conflict.
As the agreement finally brought an end to the war in Bosnia, Milošević
was credited in the West with being one of the pillars of Balkan
peace. But crucially, the Dayton Agreement did not grant amnesty for
the war crimes committed during the conflict – an omission on
Milošević's part that was to pave the way for his eventual
prosecution.
Milošević was
limited to two terms as President
of Serbia, but at the end of his term of office he instead stood
for the hitherto relatively unimportant post of President
of Yugoslavia (which by this time consisted of only Serbia and
Montenegro). He won easily and assumed office on 23
July 1997.
His old post passed into the hands of Milan
Milutinović, a political ally. In Montenegro, however, the
pro-Milošević old guard was pushed aside by the ambitious Milo
Đukanović, who became President
of Montenegro and emerged as an increasingly bitter opponent of
Milošević.
That same year, an
armed rebellion broke out in Kosovo
against Serbian rule. The separatist Kosovo
Liberation Army (KLA) began to launch attacks against Serbian
and Yugoslav security forces as well as Serbian officials and those
Albanians, Serbs and others whom the KLA regarded as "collaborators".
Although the Serbian response was initially fairly restrained, by
1998 hundreds had died in escalating retaliations and 100,000 Kosovo
Albanians were reported to have been made homeless.
The conflict
culminated in the Kosovo
War of 1999, during which over half of the province's Albanian
population fled and several thousand people died. A NATO
campaign of air strikes (Operation
Allied Force) eventually forced Milošević to back down. The
subsequent Kumanovo
Agreement saw Kosovo being handed over to a United
Nations protectorate along with the total withdrawal of Yugoslav
forces. In the aftermath of the war, the majority of Kosovo's Serb
and Roma
population fled into Serbia
proper, fearing or experiencing persecution by vengeful
Albanians and adding to the country's already large refugee
population.
This time, though,
Milošević was not lionised as a peacemaker. On 27
May 1999,
he was indicted by the ICTY for war
crimes and crimes
against humanity allegedly committed in Kosovo.
The possibility of his standing trial seemed remote at this point;
despite the loss of Kosovo, he still appeared to retain popular
support.
Downfall of
presidency
On 4
February 1997,
Milošević recognized the opposition victories in some local
elections, having contested the results for 11 weeks.
Constitutionally
limited to two terms as Serbian
president, on 23
July 1997,
Milošević assumed the presidency
of the Yugoslav Federation (currently Serbia
and Montenegro).
Armed actions by Albanian
separatist groups and Serbian police and military counter-action in
Serbia's previously autonomous (and 90% Albanian) province of Kosovo
culminated in escalating warfare in 1998, NATO
air strikes against the Federal
Republic of Yugoslavia between March and June 1999, and finally
a full withdrawal of all Yugoslav security forces from the province.
During the Kosovo
War he was indicted on 27
May 1999,
for alleged war
crimes and crimes
against humanity allegedly committed in Kosovo,
and he was standing trial,
up until his death, at the International
Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, which he asserted
was illegal, having been established in contravention of the
UN-charter.
The Yugoslav
constitution called for a second election round with all but the two
leading candidates eliminated, in the event that no candidate won
more than 50% of the vote. Official results put Koštunica ahead of
Milošević but at under 50%. Opinion polls suggested that
supporters of most of the minor candidates would go to Milošević
as would numbers of people who abstained in the first round but
would oppose an opposition supported by the NATO
powers.
Milošević's
rejection of claims of a first-round opposition victory in new
elections for the Federal presidency in September 2000 led to mass
demonstrations in Belgrade on 5
October and the collapse of the regime's authority.
Opposition-list leader Vojislav
Koštunica finally took office as Yugoslav president on 6
October when Milošević publicly accepted defeat.
Some say he was
forced to accept this reality when commanders of the army whom he
had expected to support him had indicated that in this instance they
would not. Ironically, Milošević lost his grip on power by losing
in elections which he scheduled prematurely (before the end of his
mandate) and which he did not even need to win in order to retain
power which was centred in the parliaments which his party and its
associates controlled. This downfall is known as the Bulldozer
Revolution.
Following a warrant
for his arrest by the Yugoslav authorities on charges of corruption
and abuse of power, Milošević was forced to surrender to security
forces on Saturday, 31
March 2001
following an armed stand off at his fortified villa in Belgrade. On 28
June of the same year, Milošević was transferred by Yugoslav
government officials from the gaol in Belgrade where he was being
held to United
Nations custody just inside Bosnian territory. He was then
transported to the International
Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia. The Yugoslav
Constitution explicitly prohibited extradition of Yugoslav citizens
and President Koštunica formally opposed the transfer which has
been ordered by Prime Minister Zoran
Đinđić.
Following Milošević's
transfer, the original charges of war crimes in Kosovo were upgraded
by adding charges of genocide
in Bosnia and war crimes in Croatia. On 30
January 2002,
Milošević accused the war crimes tribunal of an "evil and
hostile attack" against him. The trial began at The
Hague on 12
February 2002,
with Milošević defending himself while refusing to recognize the
legality of the court's jurisdiction.
His popularity
among the Serbs and Yugoslavs again rose sharply once the trial had
begun, as his supporters see it as a travesty of justice and
violation of national sovereignty. In addition, the rules of
procedure and the Statute of the ICTY are widely considered among
legal experts as less-than-democratic by standards of modern (U.S.)
jurisprudence (i.e. admission of hearsay as evidence, ex-post facto
changes to rules of procedure, etc.)
Milošević had a
team in Belgrade that helped him, often sending him information
available from the secret
police files. Serbian insiders often supported Milošević's
point of view, while Bosnian and Croatian witnesses have offered
much testimony supporting the indictments.
The tribunal had to
prove that Milosevic had command responsibility in Croatia and
Bosnia, at least de facto, since formally as a President
of Serbia at the time he was not in charge. His influence may
have gone beyond his formal duties, but there is little to no
evidence to support the prosecutor's case.
Milošević was not
considered by some contemporaries to be a radical nationalist
himself (although some of his followers were). Milošević's rhetoric
did not make use of hate
speech, though it may have been implied at times.
At one point during
the Yugoslav
wars, Serbia had rejected further cooperation with the Croatian
Serbs (the Republic
of Serbian Krajina), and also with the Bosnian Serbs (the Republika
Srpska, in 1993, when Serbia closed the border over the Drina
river). This action by Milosevic was regarded as treason by many
Serbs.
After the Dayton
Agreement in 1995, the Serbian nationalists (Vojislav
Šešelj's radical
party) became his sturdy opponents, up until 1998 when they
joined his party in a coalition government.