Head of the Soviet
state
On November
8, Lenin was elected as the Chairman
of the Council of People's Commissars by the Russian Soviet
Congress. Lenin emphasized the importance of bringing electricity
to all corners of Russia and to modernize industry and agriculture.
He was very concerned about creating a free universal health care
system for all, the emancipation of women, and teaching the illiterate
Russian people to read and write. But first and foremost, the new
Bolshevik government needed to take Russia out of the World
War.
Faced with the
threat of German invasion, Lenin argued that Russia should
immediately sign a peace treaty. Other Bolshevik
leaders, such as Bukharin,
advocated continuing the war as a means of fomenting revolution in
Germany. Trotsky, who led the negotiations, advocated an
intermediate position, of "No War, No Peace", calling for
a peace treaty only on the conditions that no territorial gains on
either side be consolidated. After the negotiations collapsed,
Germany launched an invasion that resulted in the loss of much of
Russia's western territory. As a result of this turn of events,
Lenin's position consequently gained the support of the majority in
the Bolshevik leadership. On March
3, 1918,
Lenin removed Russia from World War I by agreeing to the Treaty
of Brest-Litovsk, under which Russia lost significant
territories in Europe.
After the
Bolsheviks lost the elections for the Russian
Constituent Assembly, Lenin became skeptical and used his
military guards to close the first session of the Assembly on January
19. Later, the Bolsheviks organized a counter-Assembly, the
third Congress
of Soviets, allowing themselves and their allies over 90% of the
seats. [9].
They formed a coalition government with the left wing of the Socialist
Revolutionaries. However, their coalition collapsed after the
Social Revolutionaries opposed the Brest-Litovsk treaty, and they
joined other parties in seeking to overthrow the government of the
soviets. The situation degenerated, with non-Bolshevik parties (including
some of the socialist groups) actively seeking the overthrow of the
Soviet government. Lenin responded to these conspiracies by shutting
down their activities and jailing or shooting some of the members of
the opposing parties.
Even though Lenin
supported and helped to form a "Soviet
democracy," it is often argued by Lenin's opponents on the
right, like Kautsky,
and on his left, like Kollontai,
that he countermanded proletarian
emancipation and democracy (workers' control through the soviets
or workers'
councils). It is argued that this paved the road to Stalinism.
Many of the institutions and policies Stalin used such as secret
police, labor
camps, and executions of opponents were already in use under
Lenin's regime. However, Leon
Trotsky argued that a direct correlation cannot be made between
Lenin and Stalin because this perspective ignores many external
factors, such as the turmoil of revolution and civil war during
Lenin's leadership. Further Trotsky claimed that a "river of
blood" separated Lenin from Stalin's
actions because Stalin executed many of Lenin's old comrades and
their supporters, grouped in the Left
Opposition. This was indeed to include Trotsky himself.
The Leninist
vision of revolution demanded a professional revolutionary cadre
that would both lead the working masses in their conquest of power
and centralize economic and administrative power in the hands of a workers'
state. From the spring of 1918,
Lenin campaigned for a single individual to be put in charge of each
enterprise (contrary to most conceptions of workers'
self-management). As S.A. Smith wrote: "By the end of the civil
war, not much was left of the democratic forms of industrial
administration promoted by the factory
committees in 1917, but the government argued that this did not
matter since industry had passed into the ownership of a workers'
state." During the civil war, democracy would become
concentrated within the Bolshevik party and later the politburo
of the CPSU.
Lenin
proclaims Soviet power, painting by V.A.Serov
To protect the
newly-established Bolshevik government from counterrevolutionaries,
Lenin's regime created a secret police, the Cheka,
immediately after the revolution. The Bolsheviks had planned to hold
a trial for the former Tsar
for his crimes against the Russian people, but in August 1918 when
the White
Army was advancing on Yekaterinburg
(where the once royal family was being held), Sverdlov
made a quick decision to execute the Tsar and his family right away,
rather than having them being taken by the Whites. Sverdlov later
informed Lenin about this, who agreed it had been the right decision,
since the Bolsheviks would rather not have let the royal family
become a banner for the White
Movement.
On August
30, 1918,
Fanya
Kaplan, a member of the Socialist
Revolutionary Party, approached Lenin after he had spoken at a
meeting and was on the way to his car. She called out to Lenin, who
turned to answer. She immediately fired three shots, two of which
struck him in the shoulder and lung. Lenin was taken to his private
apartment in the
Kremlin, refusing to venture to a hospital since he believed
that other assassins would be waiting there. Doctors were summoned,
but decided that it was too dangerous to remove the bullets. Lenin
eventually recovered, though his health declined from this point. It
is believed that the incident contributed to his later strokes.
The Communist
government responded to the assassination attempt, and to the
increasingly mobilizing anti-communist offensive of which it was a
component, with the "Red
Terror." Tens of thousands of perceived enemies of the
Revolution, many accused of actively conspiring against the
Bolshevik government, were put in labor camps and up to 200,000
"counterrevolutionary elements" were executed. [10]
According to
Orlando Figes, Lenin had always been an advocate of "mass
terror against enemies of the revolution" and was open about
his view that the proletarian state was a system of organized
violence against the capitalist establishment. However, according to
Figes the terror, while encouraged by the Bolsheviks, had its roots
in a popular anger against the privileged. (A Peoples Tragedy,
pp524-5) When in late 1918 Kamenev and Bukharin tried to curb the
"excesses" of the Cheka, it was Lenin who defended it. (Figes
p649) However, the nature of these so-called "excesses,"
as well as Lenin's reasons behind their defense, remain unnamed.
In March, 1919,
Lenin and other Bolshevik
leaders met with revolutionary socialists from around the world and
formed the Communist
International. Members of the Communist International, including
Lenin and the Bolsheviks themselves, broke off from the broader
socialist movement. From that point onwards, they would become known
as communists.
In Russia, the Bolshevik Party was renamed the "Russian
Communist Party (Bolsheviks)," which eventually became the CPSU.
Meanwhile, the civil
war raged across Russia. A wide variety of political movements
and their supporters took up arms to support or overthrow the Soviet
government. Although many different factions were involved in the
civil war, the two main forces were the Red
Army (communists) and the White
Army (Tsarist).
Foreign powers such as France, Britain, the United States and Japan
also intervened in this war (on behalf of the White Army).
Eventually, the more organizationally proficient Red Army, led by Leon
Trotsky, won the civil war, defeating the White Russian forces
and their allies in 1920.
Smaller fights, however, continued for several more years.
"Comrade
Lenin Cleanses the Earth of Scum," 1920 Communist poster
White Army forces,
during this tumultous time of war and revolution, often themselves
"behaved with great brutality and cruelty in areas they
controlled. Towns were burned, property destroyed or stolen, peasant
farmers' crops and livestock taken by force — if people
objected, they faced torture and execution." [11]
Far from being dictated by military necessity, Brovkin has argued
that this level of terror was highly counterproductive. Alienation
of the population behind the lines can explain, according to him,
both red and white defeats during the civil war. (Behind the Front
Lines of the Civil War: Political Parties and Social Movements in
Russia, 1918-1922).
In the later months
of 1919, successes against the White Russian forces convinced Lenin
that it was time to spread the revolution to the West, by force if
necessary. When the newly independent Second
Polish Republic began securing its eastern territories annexed
by Russia in the partitions
of Poland in the late 18th
century, it clashed with Bolshevik forces for dominance in these
areas, which led to the outbreak of the Polish-Soviet
War in 1919. With the revolution
in Germany and the Spartacist
League on the rise, Lenin viewed this as the perfect time and
place to "probe Europe with the bayonets
of the Red Army." Lenin saw Poland as the bridge that the Red
Army would have to cross in order to link up the Russian Revolution
with the communist supporters in the German Revolution, and to
assist other communist movements in Western
Europe. However the defeat of Soviet Russia in the Polish-Soviet
War invalidated these plans.
Lenin was a harsh
critic of imperialism.
In 1917
he declared the unconditional right of self-determination and
separation for national minorities and oppressed nations, usually
defined as those nation-states that were previously subject to
capitalist imperial control. However, when the Russian Civil War was
won he used military force to assimilate the newly independent
nations Armenia,
Georgia,
and Azerbaijan,
arguing that the inclusion of those countries into the newly
emerging Soviet government would shelter them from capitalist
imperial ambitions. [12]
This would allow these countries admittance into the Soviet Union
rather than simply forcing them to become part of Russia as would be
in imperialist practices.
The long years of
war, the policy of War
communism, the Russian
famine of 1921, and the encirclement of the first workers' state
by hostile capitalist governments took their toll on Russia, however,
and much of the country lay in ruins. There were many peasant
uprisings, the largest being the Tambov
rebellion. After an uprising by the sailors at Kronstadt
in March 1921, Lenin replaced the policy of War
Communism with the New
Economic Policy (NEP), in a successful attempt to rebuild industry
and especially agriculture.
Lenin's struggle
against Anti-Semitism
After the
revolution, Lenin worked hard to combat Anti-Semitism,
which was still alive in Russia as a heritage of the tsarist days.
In a radio speech in 1919, Lenin said: "The tsarist police, in
alliance with the landowners and the capitalists, organized pogroms
against the Jews. The landowners and capitalists tried to divert the
hatred of the workers and peasants who were tortured by want against
the Jews. ... Only the most ignorant and downtrodden people can
believe the lies and slander that are spread about the Jews. ... It
is not the Jews who are the enemies of the working people. The
enemies of the workers are the capitalists of all countries. Among
the Jews there are working people, and they form the majority. They
are our brothers, who, like us, are oppressed by capital; they are
our comrades in the struggle for socialism. ... Shame on accursed
tsarism which tortured and persecuted the Jews. Shame on those who
foment hatred towards the Jews, who foment hatred towards other
nations."[13]
Premature death
Lenin's health had
already been severely damaged due to the intolerable strains of
revolution and war. The assassination attempt earlier in his life
also added to his health problems. The bullet was still lodged in
his neck, too close to his spine for medical techniques of the time
to remove. In May 1922, Lenin had his first stroke. He was left
partially paralyzed on his right side, and his role in government
declined. After the second stroke in December of the same year, he
resigned from active politics. In March 1923, he suffered his third
stroke and was left bedridden for the remainder of his life and no
longer able to speak.
After his first
stroke, Lenin dictated a number of papers regarding the government
to his wife. Most famous of these is Lenin's Testament, which among
other things criticized top-ranking communists such as Leon Trotsky
and Joseph
Stalin. Of Stalin, who had been the Communist Party's general
secretary since April 1922, Lenin said that he had "unlimited
authority concentrated in his hands" and suggested that "comrades
think about a way of removing Stalin from that post." Upon
Lenin's death, his wife mailed his Testament to the central
committee, to be read at the 13th Party Congress in May 1924.
However, because the will criticized all of the most prominent
figures in the central committee: Zinoviev, Kamenev, Bukharin,
Trotsky and Stalin, the committee had a vested interest in not
releasing the will to the wider public. The central committee
justified this by claiming that Lenin had been mentally ill in his
final years and, as such, his final judgments were not to be trusted.
Disregarding the words of Lenin is thought by most to be a fatal
error, however, as he was apparently the only one to recognize the
danger of allowing Stalin to take over party control.
Lenin died on January
21 1924 at age 53. Rumors of Lenin having syphilis
sprang up shortly after his death. The official cause given for
Lenin's death was cerebral arteriosclerosis, or a fourth stroke. But
out of the 27 physicians who treated him, only eight signed onto
that conclusion in his autopsy report. Therefore, several other
theories regarding his death have been put forward. For example, a
posthumous diagnosis by two psychiatrists and a neurologist recently
published in the European Journal of Neurology claimed to show that
Lenin died from syphilis.
Documents released
after the fall of the U.S.S.R., along with memoirs of Lenin's
physicians, suggest that Lenin was treated for syphilis as early as
1895. Documents also suggest that Alexei
Abrikosov, the pathologist in charge of the autopsy, was ordered
to prove that Lenin did not die of syphilis. Abrikosov did not
mention syphilis in the autopsy; however, the blood-vessel damage,
the paralysis and other incapacities he cited are typical of
syphilis. Upon a second release of the autopsy report, none of the
organs, major arteries, or brain areas usually affected by syphilis
were cited.
In 1923, Lenin's
doctors treated him with Salvarsan,
the only drug at the time specifically used to treat syphilis, and potassium
iodide, which was also customary at the time in treating the
disease.
Although he might
have had syphilis, so did a large percentage of Russians at this
time. Also, he had no visible lesions anywhere on his body that
accompany the later stages of the disease. Most historians still
agree that the most likely cause of his death was a stroke induced
by the bullet still lodged in his neck from the assassination
attempt.
The city of
Petrograd was renamed Leningrad
in his honor three days after Lenin's death; this remained the name
of the city until the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, when it
reverted to its original name, St Petersburg.
At his funeral,
Lenin's body was wrapped in the remains of a red flag preserved from
the Paris
Commune, an event that he described as an example of the "Dictatorship
of the Proletariat".
During the early
1920s the Russian movement of cosmism
was quite popular and there was an intent to cryonically preserve
Lenin's body in order to revive him in the future. Necessary
equipment was purchased abroad, but for a variety of reasons the
plan was not realized. Instead his body was embalmed and placed on
permanent exhibition in the Lenin
Mausoleum in Moscow on January
27, 1924.
After death
Lenin's preserved
body is on permanent display at the Lenin
Mausoleum in Moscow. Due to Lenin's unique role in the creation
of the first Communist state, and despite his expressed wish shortly
before his death that no memorials be created for him, his character
was elevated over time to the point of near religious reverence. By
the 1980's, every major city in the Soviet Union had a statue of
Lenin in its central square, either a Lenin street or a Lenin square
near the center, and often 20 or more smaller statues and busts
throughout its territory. Collective
farms, medals,
hybrids of wheat, and even asteroids
(852
Wladilena) were named after him. Children were taught stories
about "granddaddy Lenin" while they were still in
kindergarten, quite similar to the adulation afforded to the
Founding Fathers in US schools.
Since the fall of
the Soviet Union, the level of reverence for Lenin in post-Soviet
republics has gone down considerably, but he is still considered an
important figure by the people who grew up during the Soviet period.
Many statues of Lenin have been torn down, but many still remain.
The city of Leningrad was returned to its original name, St
Petersburg, but the surrounding Oblast still carries his name.
The citizens of Ulyanovsk,
Lenin's birthplace, have so far resisted all attempts to revert its
name to Simbirsk. The subject of interring Lenin's body has been a
recurring topic for the last 16 years in Russia.
Lenin's brain
study
Lenin on an
old Soviet bill
Lenin's brain
was removed before his body was embalmed.
The Soviet
government commissioned the well-known German neuroscientist Oskar
Vogt to study Lenin's brain and to locate the precise location
of the brain cells that are responsible for Lenin's supposed "genius"[2].
The study was performed in Vladimir
Bekhterev's Institute of the Brain. Vogt published a paper on
the brain in 1929 where he reported that some pyramidal
neurons in the third layer of Lenin's cerebral
cortex were very large. However the conclusion of its relevance
to genius was contested. Vogt's work was considered unsatisfactory
by the Soviets. Further research was continued by the Soviet team,
but the work on Lenin's brain was no longer publicised.
Contemporary anatomists
are no longer convinced that morphology
alone can determine the functioning of the brain; see craniometry
for more details.
Censorship of
Lenin in the Soviet Union
Lenin's writings
were carefully censored under the Soviet regime after his death. In
the early 1930s, it became accepted dogma under Stalin to assume
that neither Lenin nor the Central Committee could ever be wrong.
Therefore, it was necessary to remove evidence of situations where
they had actually disagreed, since in those situations it was
impossible for both to have been right at the same time. Trotsky was
a particularly vocal critic of these practices, which he saw as a
form of deification of a mere human being who could, and did, make
mistakes. [14]
Later, even the fifth complete Soviet edition of Lenin's
works (published in 55 thick volumes between 1958 and 1965) left out
parts that either contradicted dogma or showed their author in too
poor a light.[15]